The performance of VCI paper and VCI film in terms of VCI effect varies. The specific advantages and disadvantages depend on the usage environment, storage conditions and VCI requirements. Generally speaking, VCI films usually have good protective performance because they can provide a closed environment where VCI gases can be evenly released inside the packaging and effectively protect the metal surface. VCI film can maintain a certain gas concentration, making its VCI effect last for a longer time, especially under sealed packaging. However, the VCI effect of VCI paper is relatively weak because it does not provide a closed environment, and the VCI gas is prone to escape. The protective effect is more dependent on the coverage range and exposure time of the paper.
Therefore, within the same period of time, the VCI effect of VCI film is usually better than that of VCI paper, especially when long-term and comprehensive protection is required. VCI paper is suitable for short-term protection or situations where packaging requirements are relatively loose. It is usually appropriate for packaging that does not require complete sealing. VCI films, on the other hand, are more suitable for long-term storage or transportation processes where there are higher requirements for VCI effects. The appropriate packaging materials should be selected based on the specific application environment and rust prevention requirements.